What are "add backs"?

In the course of a separation, a critical question to be asked is, ‘What happens to money that is spent before the property settlement is finalised?’

For many years, the Court would use a tool called “add backs,” where it would take the property of the parties or either of them as it finds at the date of trial and treat that property as if it was still in the pool of assets.

Example of the spending of funds includes:

  • using joint money for legal fees;
  • withdrawing large sums of cash;
  • gambling or wasting money
  • making other questionable purchases (“wastage”)

What happened in Shinohara & Shinohara [2025] FedCFamC1A 126?

In Shinohara, the couple had a five-year marriage and an asset pool of about $616,000. It was agreed between the parties that the money used for legal fees should be added back into the pool.

However, the Full Court put an end to this long-established family law practice.

The Court interpreted the amended section 79 provisions following the Family Law Amendment Act 2024 (Cth), and confirmed that as “notional property” (money that has already been spent) no longer exists, it cannot be treated as “property” under section 79(3)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) when the Court is making property adjustment orders pursuant to section 79(1):

The text of s 79(3)(a)(i) is clear. Only the existing property of the parties is to be identified and only that existing property is to be divided or adjusted ([121])

Nevertheless, the Court reasoned that while addbacks should no longer appear on the balance sheet, they remain relevant to the Court’s broader discretionary exercise when assessing each party’s contributions and when making adjustments to ensure a fair outcome:

As notional property does not exist, it cannot be identified to form part of the balance sheet recording the current items of the parties' property ([127]).

What does this mean in practice?

This decision means courts can no longer simplify “add back” money that has been spent. Instead, they must take a holistic approach, considering:

  • Contributions: looking at what each person put into the relationship (financially and otherwise)
  • Adjustments: making percentage shifts to ensure the outcome is fair

For instance, if one person spends joint money in a way that disadvantages the other party, the court may compensate the other person by awarding them a larger share of what remains, rather than notionally adding the money back.

DISCLAIMER: The information provided above is published for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be nor should it be relied upon as a substitute for legal or other advice.